Showing posts with label economic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economic. Show all posts

Sunday, April 1, 2012

Do Not Tolerate Poverty


"However there should be no poor among you. For in the land the Lord your God is giving you to possess as your inheritance, he will richly bless you, if only you fully obey the Lord your God . . . (Deuteronomy 15:4-5)."

Amazingly I shared this with a church leader last week and she responded, "you must be a socialist." We
were discussing the greed and exploitation that the oil companies (with the assistance of Congress and the Supreme Court) continue to inflict on the American consumers. One of the things I have learned these past six years is that when you attempt to be faithful to the One who is unconditional love apart from faithfulness to His Word, you will come under the influence of deceptive spirits. These spirits have captured the minds of many American Christians causing us to live with a false consciousness and many delusions.

The Word of God is very clear on the subject of poverty. Jesus said that those who followed him must not only adhere to this Word (the Hebrew Bible) but to the "spirit of the law" as well. So verse one of this chapter begins, "At the end of seven years you must cancel all debts." Verse seven reads, "If there is a poor man among you. . . do not be hardhearted or tightfisted. . . ." Verse eight continues, "Rather be openhanded and freely lend him whatever he needs." Verse ten concludes the matter, "Give generously to him and do so without a grudging heart; then because of this the Lord your God will bless you in all your work and in everything that you put your hand to."

This is not good capitalism--neither is it necessarily socialism. It is faithful discipleship. Those who follow God are not only held accountable for these commandments, but are promised a blessing in everything that you put your hand to." Those who have paid off Congress to keep student loan rates high, who think a free college and graduate school education for all who qualify is unthinkable, to bristle at paying any tax dollars to support free national health care--and claim to be followers of Jesus of Nazareth, the incarnation of God's unconditional love--are deluding themselves, and robbing the community of faith of its real power and blessing. God is watching and will hold us accountable for our spiritual captivity to the god of greed.

Sunday, January 15, 2012

Dr. King's Economic Justice: OUR UNFINISHED WORK



For he will deliver the needy who cry out, the afflicted who have no one to help.  He will take pity on the poor and the needy, and save the weak from death (Psalm 72:12-13).

Listen, my dear brothers: Has not God chosen those who are poor in the eyes of the world to be rich in faith, and to inherit the kingdom he promised those who love him (James 2:5)?”

You trample on the poor and force him to give you grain . . . .  You oppress the righteous and take bribes, and you deprive the poor of justice in the courts (Amos 5:11-12).

*        *        *

On a Thursday evening, the 10th of November last year, a 37-year old man, a Christian, and an active member of his church was arrested and charged with bank robbery and the murder of a police officer.  After allegedly robbing the Bank of America in Vallejo, California, he fled the pursuit of a 45-year-old, 19-year veteran of the police department there-also a Christian.  Both men were married, fathers of children.  The 37-year-old suspect was out of work.  He had been convicted of crimes before, but had stayed out of trouble for more than 11 years, and had seemingly turned his life around, becoming a responsible member of the community.

The alleged assailant had been unemployed for more than a year and the family home was about to be foreclosed on.  It is speculated that his financial troubles may have been behind his seeming spiral into violence.

The officer was not only a 19-year veteran patrolman with a spotless record, but he was a pillar of the community.  He was committed in word and deed to improving the quality of life for at-risk urban youth in Vallejo, California.  He volunteered as a basketball coach for the local high school, a community center, and in fact had served as a role model for one of the associate pastors of his alleged slayer’s church.  The community was hit hard, grieving both for the slain officer and the family of the alleged slayer.  It appears that though devout and sincere in his faith and his personal transformation, the alleged assailant was unable to hold it together against the economic strain his family faced.  His church’s general negation of the social crises around them in favor of preparing members for prosperity on earth, and encouraging them in their individual spiritual growth and authority as they await heaven, was unable to stem his penchant for criminal activity and his return to the same when he found the promised prosperity disappearing around him. 

The so-called issues of the Social Gospel are the issues of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. The exploitation, abuse and injustice leveled by the rich and powerful against the poor are themes in the burden of the Prophets, the Law of Moses, the compassion of Siddhartha, and several Surahs of the Qur’an. 

The church can spiritualize and ignore the real problems of real human beings all it wants, or like some mainline communions, it can cater to the middle and upper classes and get amnesia about the very people that John Wesley dedicated himself to in England, and Richard Allen in America: The poor, the marginalized, the outcast, and those who were being used as human machines for plantations and the new industrial revolution.  Yet these issues do not go away and will continue to have an adverse effect on our people.  Furthermore God will judge us for this neglect, this apathy, this rush to comfort, acceptability and popularity that we seem so compelled to pursue.

*        *        *

On November 27, 1967, Dr Martin Luther King Jr. and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference organized a Poor People's Campaign to address issues of economic justice and housing for the poor in the United States, aiming itself at rebuilding America's cities . . . . Martin Luther King Jr. labeled the Poor People's Campaign the "second phase," of the civil rights struggle - setting goals such as gathering activists to lobby Congress for an "Economic Bill of Rights," Dr. King also saw a crying need to confront a Congress that demonstrated its "hostility to the poor " - appropriating "military funds with alacrity and generosity," but providing "poverty funds with miserliness."

Under the "economic bill of rights" the Poor People's Campaign asked for the federal government to prioritize helping the poor with an antipoverty package that included housing and a guaranteed annual income for all Americans.  Dr. King pointed out that "the wealthy who own securities have always had a guaranteed income, and the relief client, has been guaranteed an income, however miniscule, through welfare benefits."  For this reason he argued that the guaranteed income should be "progressive, set at the median income of society rather than at the bottom," and that it should "automatically increase with inflation."

Dr. King had recently published, Where Do we Go from Here: Chaos of Community (1967). In that book, Dr. King called for the complete economic redistribution of wealth in America.  He wrote further:

          Up to recently, we have proceeded from a premise that poverty is a consequence of multiple evils: lack of education restricting job opportunities; poor housing which stultified home life and suppressed initiative, and fragile family     relationships, which distorted personality development.

Dr. King went on to explain in that same chapter of the book:

          I am now convinced that the simplest approach will prove to   be the most effective—the solution to poverty is to abolish it    directly by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.  . . .  We are likely to find that the attempt to eliminate the problems of housing and education, instead of preceding the elimination of poverty, will themselves be affected if poverty is first abolished....  

          The curse of poverty has no justification in our age . . . . The time has come for us to civilize ourselves by the total, direct and immediate abolition of poverty.

We have now gone full circle.  While King’s birthday celebration approaches the vulgar corporate secularism of Christmas, or of a pre-convention political rump session, where the most opportunistic of people with money and power dominate the platforms proclaiming their allegiance to something nebulously referred to as King’s Dream, most fail to remember his speech of December 24, 1967, in which he stated,
"In 1963...in Washington, D.C....I Tried to talk to the nation about a dream that I had had, and I must confess...that not long after talking about that dream I started seeing it turn into a nightmare.”

In an interview with NPR regarding the Poor Peoples’ Campaign on Dr. King’s birthday, 2008, the Reverend Joseph Lowery stated:

"The nation became conscious of the fact that it has an expanding poor population," says Lowery, who co-founded the Southern Christian Leadership Conference with King. "It's one thing to have the right to check into the Hiltons and the Marriotts, it's another thing to have the means to check out."
For many of America's poor, there hasn't been much progress in the 40 years since the Poor People's Campaign. In 1968, 25 million people — nearly 13 percent of the population — were living below the poverty level, according to the Census Bureau. In 2006, 36 million people or more than 12 percent of the population were living below the poverty level.
Poverty has been rapidly rising for some time.  The black middle class, in fact the entire American middle class in a recent report from NewsMax, is disappearing all over the country.  Opportunities for higher education are evaporating, even for those who would attend public colleges and universities.  The dropout rate, murder rate and the incarceration rates for black and brown boys and men is outrageous, and growing for black and brown women. 


The ranks of jobless and homeless people are growing exponentially while the gap between rich and poor accelerates. Wealth is more concentrated in the hands of the few. “Pew reported last week that there is a growing rift and resentment between rich and poor in America, due in part to “the underlying shifts in the distribution of wealth in American society.” Pew also reported, “According to the most recent U.S. Census Bureau data, the proportion of overall wealth — a measure that includes home equity, stocks and bonds, and the value of jewelry, furniture and other possessions — held by the top 10 percent of the population increased from 49 percent in 2005 to 56 percent in 2009.”  Democracy itself has vanished or is vanishing as corporate lobbyists exercise almost complete control over the U. S. House of Representative and the Senate. 




*       *        *
So where are the organizations that are addressing King’s economic vision for America?  Where are the progressive economists, business people, educators, clergy and laity who will collectively lift up his vision for economic democracy in America in 2012?  I’m not simply talking about giving speeches like this one, even though more are certainly needed from our too heavenly-spiritually preoccupied churches, mosques, and synagogues. 

One sign of hope has been the Occupy-Move On Movements.  Yet I have heard so much criticism from clergy and other leaders regarding these movements.  I would challenge those critics, put up or shut up.  It is black people and then brown people in America who are disproportionately losing their homes, unable to send qualified children to college, and lacking the funds and resources to keep our children out of the “cradle to the grave prison pipeline.”  The prison industrial complex is growing rapidly.  Many young lawyers are eager to become ADAs so that they can incarcerate more black and brown, men women and children by any means necessary, using this as a stepping-stone to corporate and political careers.  


A sizable number of this army of attorneys are busy working with banks and mortgage companies, helping them to find legal loopholes whereby they can further exploit and suck dollars away from we who are still managing to hold on to our businesses, jobs and homes.

*        *         *        *

Poverty and Faith
Over the past few years, mega-churches have become more popular in black communities, just as they have in white communities. These mega-churches have amassed influence and wealth partly because of their sheer number of parishioners. Some have created satellite churches and broadcast their gospel on television.
On April 3, 1968, in his famous “Promised Land” sermon, Dr. King said, “It's all right to talk about ‘long white robes over yonder,’ in all of its symbolism. But ultimately people want some suits and dresses and shoes to wear down here.  It's all right to talk about ‘streets flowing with milk and honey,’ but God has commanded us to be concerned about the slums down here, and his children who can't eat three square meals a day. It's all right to talk about the New Jerusalem, but one day, God's preacher must talk about the new New York, the new Atlanta, the New Philadelphia, the new Los Angeles, and the new Memphis, Tennessee. This is what we have to do.”
This having been said, I would challenge us to adhere to, trust in, reverence, and rely on God.  We need to turn to the pages of the Bible in order to get ourselves back into focus.  We need to recommit ourselves to our first love.  I have no problem in proclaiming that Jesus Christ is both Lord and Deliverer, the savior, the one that God has chosen to bring light and love and truth and hope to the world.  In one of his 1934 readings, the late Prophet Edgar Cayce spoke of the Christ, "Not as only one, but the only one."


We need people who are unapologetically Christian, instead of this wishy-washy “everything is everything” rhetoric that is driving our children elsewhere.  It is God who advocates for us, who has already commissioned Jesus to lead the hosts of heaven in winning every political and economic battle for us, and who is outraged at the state of our planet, but especially at the state of ease, comfort, entertainment, lazy thinking and the absence of thinking and doing and loving in the church. 




One of the hard lessons I have learned is that those who ignore and minimize the sacred texts do so, not because they consider the words archaic or anachronistic or erroneous, but rather because they would rather not be confronted with the expectations God places on us in the scriptures.  It is easy to criticize fundamentalists and evangelicals for having otherworldly views, but I frankly see no strong commitment to economic justice coming from much of the liberal wing of the church.  Our seminaries are in full retreat, having students focus on something nebulous that the majority culture calls “spirituality.”  I grew up in a church where spirituality meant, “Let justice roll down like water, and righteousness like a flowing stream.” 

In fact people like Jim Wallace of Sojourners and Dr. Herbert Daughtry of the House of the Lord Pentecostal Church, Brooklyn, N. Y., are some of the strongest advocates for economic justice for the poor in America.  Rev. Daughtry is no stranger to us, having worked closely with Rev, Jesse Jackson and the Reverend Al Sharpton and having founded in 1982, the African People's Christian Organization. 

The liberal church of which Dr. King was certainly representative and which nurtured him in his ideological understanding of what God requires, is now marching in lock-step with the rich and powerful under the banner of “neo-liberalism.” The name of its game is accommodation-ism, and it will bend over backwards and bow down to Hell rather than offend its rich classist, heterosexist, racist donors and benefactors and its upper middle class and upper class constituencies.

Dr. William Edward Burghardt Du Bois, the father of American sociology, was often criticized for being a tad bit elitist and detached.  In 1899, while he was working on his great study, The Philadelphia Negro as a faculty member of Atlanta University, the Wilmington Massacre occurred.  As many as a hundred lives were lost.  Much of the black community in Wilmington, North Carolina known as Brooklyn, had been burned to the ground, and thousands of black residents fled for their lives.

The city had been a bastion of the black middle and upper classes in the south, with a population of 11,324 African Americans and 8,731 whites.   All this was to change overnight.  The Democrats were determined to remove all of the black political appointees that President McKinley had made, in gratitude for the role that African Americans had played in the Spanish-American war.  The Democrats recruited farmers in the outlying areas, whites whose wives were forced to find jobs and work for blacks in the state’s cotton mills in the city. 


Their strategy was to shame whites, just as the Republicans are now doing, into voting for "white economic interests" using racial code language.  With the help of right-wing fringe groups and respectable church liberals like Rebecca Felton of the WCTU, they enflamed the white people of the city and surrounding communities.  Felton quoted her mentor, the vitriolic white supremacist WCTU founder Frances Willard, who had stated publicly that "white women needed to be protected from marauding, inebriated black men," who Williard had also characterized as "fierce beasts." This led to the lynching and mutilation of Samuel Wilkes, which was the catalyst to the massacre.  He was cut, mutilated and parts of his charred remains sold all over the south.  

Du Bois, who was startled by the gruesome murder, had written a sober anti-lynching editorial that he was going to give to Atlanta Constitution’s editor Joel Chandler Harris.  With his walking cane and gloves, Du Bois made his way to the newspaper office, but was stopped short when he passed by a shop on Mitchell Street, where Wilke’s charred knuckles were on display.  It was then that Du Bois realized as he wrote later: “One could not be a calm, cool, and detached scientist while Negroes were lynched, murdered, and starved.

I would challenge all who hear and read these words to consider the state of our race, of our nation, and really ask whether or not we can continue to delay or ignore Dr. King’s challenge of economic justice for America.  I would ask us to consider whether or not the time for detachment and sensible responses is over. Perhaps the Occupy Movement is a cue for us to develop a serious program that continues Dr. King’s work for economic justice in America.  I would challenge us to consider those who are starved, excluded, incarcerated, exploited, and have their dreams dashed by those who are interested in quick profits that leave the people hopeless and powerless.  We cannot keep men, women and children out of the criminal justice system with just good intentions.

I know that the Lord secures justice for the poor and upholds the cause of the needy (Psalm 140:12).

Woe to him who builds his realm by unjust gain, to set his nest on high, to escape the clutches of ruin!  You have plotted the ruin of many peoples, shaming your own house and forfeiting your life (Habakkuk 2:9).

So I will come near to you for judgment.  I will be quick to testify against . . . those who defraud laborers of their wages, who oppress the widows and the fatherless, and deprive aliens of justice, but do not fear me (Malachi 3:5).

What will we do with Dr. King’s call for economic justice in 2012?

Don Guest

Monday, January 9, 2012

Proper Charitable Giving


“The Lord is a refuge for the oppressed, a stronghold in times of trouble.  Those who know your name will trust in you, for you, Lord, have never forsaken those who seek you (Psalm 9:9-10)."

Spike Lee’s classic “Do the Right Thing” presents a picture of the world as too many of us know it.  Those who have power abuse it and live with arrogant disdain for the poor.  Some of us who live with the privilege of power, who claim to be guided by moral and religious principles or our own “sense of right and wrong” too often are paternalistic social “do-gooders” who “want to do good” as long as we don’t have to make any real sacrifices.  We are the most vocal supporters of charity as long as our own comfortable lifestyle with its innate cultural and social boundaries is not put at risk.  We often have more sympathy for our dogs and cats and “free range green farm chickens” than we do for the outcast, feared and despised poor of our world. 

In the 10th chapter of the Gospel of Mark, the writer conveys this story:  As Jesus started in his way a man ran up to him and fell on his feet before him, “Good Rabbi,” he asked, “What must I do to inherit eternal life?”  “Why do you call me good?” Jesus answered, “No one is good—except God alone.  You know the commandments, ‘Do not murder, do not commit adultery, do not steal, do not give false testimony in court, do not cheat the poor, honor your father and mother.’”  “Teacher,” he declared, “all these I have kept since I was a boy.”  Jesus looked at him and loved him.  “One thing you lack,” he said, “Go sell everything you have and give it to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come follow me.”  At this the man’s face fell.  He went away sad because he had great wealth (Mark 10:17-22).”

Jesus was not trying to make it impossible for this man to become one of his followers.  On the other hand, Jesus was far more sophisticated in his thinking and understanding about charity than some churches and Christian leaders would have us believe.  He warned the man that God was not looking for “good people” but for people who would allow God’s agenda to transform their own conceptualization of themselves.  He did not want to mislead people about what God required of them.

Jesus wanted us to understand the nature of what God wanted for the world.  It would not be achieved by soliciting donations from the disposable incomes of middle and upper class persons for soup kitchens or the other worthwhile social causes that churches and charitable organizations engaged in.  Something more intense, yet simple was required.

Jesus knew that these acts in and of themselves had nothing to do with making life any better for the recipients, nor for the ones who were the benefactors.  Too often our “goodness” is based on our own social class position, which affords us “the choice” of “helping” the poor.  For Jesus it was not a matter of charity but of lifestyle choice.  To live in accordance with God’s plan meant that self and all that made one feel important and powerful enough to “help” others, must be abandoned.  Only relying on the goodness of God (no strings attached LOVE) and not the goodness of human beings changes the world.  One theologian wrote of God's motive as "total disinterestedness."  

In the January 7th One-Year Bible reading we read in the Gospel of Matthew: “Be careful not to do your acts of righteousness before men, to be seen by them.  If you do you will have no reward from your Father in heaven.  So when you give to the needy do not announce it with trumpets, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and on the streets, to be honored by men.  I tell you the truth; they have received their reward in full.  But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your giving may be in secret.  Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret will reward you (Wow!  Seems like we have institutionalized in our faith communities the very thing that Jesus warned us NOT TO DO—advertising, honoring and reporting on those who give for our good work—Matthew 6:1-4).”

The poor are more suspect of the latter than they are of brutal police, overt white supremacists, the “cradle to the grave prison-pipeline of the criminal ‘just-us’ system, and right wing ideologues.  It appears to the poor, marginalized of society that us “do-gooders” do not really “see them” or really ‘regard them” as the same human beings that we are.  They do not sense that we understand them to have the same needs, the same aspirations, the same blood that bleeds when cut, the same bodies that die when they don’t receive adequate health care, the same minds that are wasted without quality education, and the same psyches and souls that are wounded, often beyond repair, by the abject poverty and lack of resources they must contend with in the ghettos (worn out used “flat-lands” housing, playgrounds--when they do exist, schools, stores and infrastructures) they are consigned to live in. 

We never seem to connect the massive profits our businesses or our stocks, IRAs, pensions and capital investments are making with the growing rampant joblessness, homelessness, drop-out rates and incarcerations that so tragically characterize ever-growing segments of the American population. 

It’s kind of like what I wrote about in a previous post regarding Chevron Oil.  Chevron’s giving 3.7 million dollars to social service agencies in Richmond, and then simultaneously seeking to take back $60 million from the taxes they paid to the county—after having already sued and gotten $120 million in taxes back from the county for previous years, is the worst kind of cynical greed and disregard for the well-being of American citizens.  Add this to their hundreds of billions of dollars of profits each year, their charitable giving amounts to a heinous joke—a pittance “in the name of” offering remedy for the social conditions that their refusal to pay a fair share of taxes has helped to create and exacerbate in that same city.  Those who scramble for these dollars miss the larger picture of how their "gratitude" and "competition" feeds the misery of the very people they believe they are helping.

It's like Jewish guards in the Warsaw Ghetto believing that they were helping Jews by carrying out the orders of the Germans to keep order there.  In reality, such social service agencies become the de facto agents of those who would inflict misery and suffering on the poor in favor or more profits.  Those who ignore the Bible’s clear teaching in favor of their own contemporary religious-ethical spin on charity do the same thing.

But in this song from the Hebrew Psalter (9:9-10), it is clear that the poor are not to seek out the assistance of “good human beings” or “progressive human beings.”

Neither are the poor to put their trust in pastors or politicians or corporate leaders.

The poor are to put their trust, to put their hope in, and to rely upon God (no strings attached LOVE). The oppressed are told that the LORD (YHWH) Adonai, or Jehovah--the God of "WHAT WILL BE" is their refuge.  The almighty sovereign Creator is the Fortress, the Strong Shield “in times of trouble,” and the One who ultimately brings a new reality for all.  


You want to help the poor?  Then teach the poor God’s name--after you have learned to call on that name for your own very breath and life and health.  You want to assist the poor?  Teach the poor to trust, to have hope in the One who loves them even as you trust and hope and embrace that same love.  Admit to the poor that too often they suffer because too often we too often fear and despise them.  Teach the poor that we cannot save them or even ourselves, but that God rescues them and will rescue us all who live by faith in God's unconditional love.  God does and will do this not because of what we do or have done, not because we are better or smarter than the right or the left, but because God loves all of us equally and in spite of our sins, our mistakes and our fears. 

Teach the poor that they must not define themselves by the poverty of a sub-culture of desperation, limited choices and the loathsomeness that we transfer off to them from our own fear and false consciousness, and that they also define themselves by.  Confess to the poor that our attitudes and fears have contributed to their suffering and ask the poor for their forgiveness.

God loves all of us, but the Bible is clear that God has a preferential option for the poor (Matthew 6:19-21; Luke 1:46-55).  God’s message is that the poor, like us, are fearfully and wonderfully made, and are the “apple of God’s eye.”  In fact THEY are US-- if we truly understand the concept of God’s new heaven and new earth.  We are all in training for another time, another place, and another world where love, mercy and truth are the order of the day. 

We have an opportunity to live in humility instead arrogance.  It is never too late for us to change our behavior and approach (repentance-metanoia).  God calls us through the Hebrew Bible, The Christian Bible and the Holy Qur'an to encourage the poor and outcast to join with us, be a part of us, have the best seats in our churches, our mosques, and our synagogues, attend our schools with our children, house themselves in our neighborhoods--our "hills," join life with our families, our social clubs, our community councils, work with us and share the fruits of labor in our businesses, our corporations, and have a place in our future, and join with us at decision-making tables as equals in seeking solutions that lessen the suffering of all human beings until Christ returns. 

The poor will no longer be victimized by anyone on the same day that we decide to “let the poor become a part of us.”  Seems like too much, a tall order.  The song of Psalm 9 concludes, “For you Lord have never forsaken those who seek you.”